No Steam Controller 2 for me, thanks

Out of steam

I changed my mind, I don’t want one.

Black glossy gamepad with two circular touch pads, the left one has a groove resembling a dpad, a joystick and four face buttons.
[Steam Controller]

First of all, this is Valve, a bad company, that is notorious for only caring about profit, so it can easily abandon the project and stop supporting it. I’m not singling them out, commercial companies do that, but that’s my point: I don’t trust any of them. And I don’t trust the open source community to carry the torch, no offense.

And it needs support: it’s software based, which is my personal nightmare. A piece of hardware that is useless on its own? Horrible! That’s why I’ve been looking at mice with on-board memory.

And that’s why I’m more or less satisfied with so-called elite/pro/whatever gamepads, because they work as gamepads by themselves. If I can have a gamepad with four programmable back buttons, I’m 90% there: it’s a sweet spot between simplicity and customization.

Because customization is the greatest feature of a Steam Controller. It’s also its biggest drawback: it needs to be customized. Pads are not sticks, nor are they a mouse. They are, in my opinion, better, but only if you willing to spend time tinkering with them. A lot.

I realize that this falls into the “you want perfection but you only got good enough” category, and for some people a Steam Controller or something like it is more of an accessibility aid than it is for me.

All of this is based on my experience with the Steam Controller, which I got on day one. I liked it right away, I never had any complaints about the shape or anything like that. Steam Input (the software part, basically) was good enough to start with, and it got better over time. But after a couple of years I realized that the drawbacks outweighed the benefits: I tinkered more than I played. And in another couple of years Valve decided to rewrite the software and, at least in my opinion, made it worse.

Black handheld device, with a screen in the middle and gamepad part on both sides: a square touchpad and a joystick on each side, dpad on the left and face buttons on the right.
[Steam Deck]

That’s also why I don’t want a Steam Deck. It’s like those old TV combos that have a VHS or DVD player built in. One thing goes out and bye-bye the whole deal.

I also realize that the reason we are not getting Steam Controller 2 may be much simpler: a lawsuit.

Bottom line, I know myself and I like gamepads. And if there’s an interesting new one, there’s a good chance I’ll get it, even if I clearly don’t need one. But it would have to be really, really interesting, and a true successor to the Steam Controller is at the bottom of that list.

Summary for October 2024

Divine Beasts

Two scelettons, holding spiked clubs from which hang pieces of colethes, face each other in a torch-lit dingeon. There is a dialogue box on the screen where one of the sceletons says “Best not to think about it. I don’t want to fall to bits ‘cos of excess existential thought. Nasty…”.
[Divine Divinity]

Divine Divinity is a game from the era when attitude was a valid substitute for humor, message, or even story. So it is a bit surprising that it is very restrained. Not without its eyebrow raising moments, but nothing worth calling out, I think.

Starting with the good, it makes me more interested in what else Larian has done (I’ve already dipped my toes into some of their games, but no more than that). There’s also the bad: it’s a bit junky and its difficulty is uneven, to say the least: I only finished it by cheating my ass off. Do I regret playing it? No. Can I recommend it? Eh-h-h…

Princess Zelda, blonde elf in a blue shirt, dark pants and shoes, and a Tablet PC-like magical device called the Sheikah Slate on her belt. She uses a power of Magnesis, which looks like a big magnet in her hands, to smash a huge metal crate into a bunch of bokoblins (pig-like humanoids) and lizalfos (bipedal chameleons). There are a lot of them around, waiting for a fight.
[Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity]

Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity is in its own subgenre, but it’s basically a beat-them-up. It can be repetitive, but on easy is at least not demanding. It tells the alternative history version of the backstory of Breath of the Wild, and manages to tour through it’s world, bringing most of the notable characters (with some very surprising choices@) along the way. Fan service-y? Sure, but still easy-going fun and a good excuse to revisit this world for the third time.

Communication in games

Come, you, nya cat

At this point, I accept that I will never play another tabletop roleplaying game again. Or any video game with similar level of engagement between players. Consider, that to play something like this, you need:

  1. friends,
  2. …who play games,
  3. …who play the same games you do,
  4. …at the same time as you.

Or dealing with strangers online? Nope.

Partially because of this, and partially because it’s a fascinating thing in itself, I’ve been interested in games that approach this problem: games that require some coordination between players (otherwise why talk at all?) but don’t use (or at least don’t require) text or voice chat.

I wonder what was the first multiplayer game where jumping became a form of communication. Probably the first multiplayer game with jumping in it 🙂

Splatoon can be kind of a level zero. The game is simple enough that you can just play cooperatively and it works. Like with any game, there are ways to talk to your friends, and a coordinated team would be better, but it’s not necessary to have fun.

Two characters wearing red ponchos, hoods and scarves with gold trim and white symbols, similar to the clothes worn by characters in the game Journey. They are standing in a glittering, magical-looking desert, looking at a silhouette of a distant castle hidden in the clouds.
[Sky: Children of the Light]

Games like Journey and Sky: Children of the Light go for something simple, like Splatoon, but they also invent their own thing. Calling it a language is a stretch, but there is communication. If you think about it, a lot of human communication is non-verbal anyway, and this is no different. And when it works, it’s very special.

Apex Legend’s ping ability is brilliant. It’s even useful if you use the voice chat that the game has. If you are not familiar with it, you just have a special button that you press while pointing at something and your character would say something appropriate. You can warn about the enemy, you can say that there is an item on the ground, or even that you need ammo for your gun. It is great.

You can throw the entire Dark Souls Extended Cinematic Universe in here as games that have gestures. And I find that the vast majority of people actually roleplay in these games. Sure, there are not a lot of ways to not do that, but I still think it is a design choice and a good one. When someone attacks you or helps you, it feels appropriate to the world of the game.

In a green, lush forest that looks like a paper diorama, two small figures wave to each other across the river.
[Book of Travels]

There are a lot of other games that do something similar or maybe very different that I haven’t played or have forgotten. For example, I am still trying to figure out what the hell Book of Travels even is.

Summary for September 2024

A whole wide witchy world

A very small figure of April Ryan, a short-haired brunette, stands on a country road. There are some small wooded buildings, probably a house and a barn, off to her left, with huge sunflower-like flowers behind a small fence. To her right, there is a small herd of animals that looks like an elephant-bull hybrid. Further out, lush green mountains, stretching far into a bluish haze under fluffy white clouds. There are also two huge statues of humanoids blowing into horns.
[The Longest Journey]

I don’t need a “it’s a game from a quarter of a century ago” qualifier to say that The Longest Journey is a great game. Because there is not much to qualify. Sure, it’s not perfect, nothing is. But the story is good, the puzzles are logical, it’s still pretty and very charming. Quite progressive in places@, too.

Like many fairy tales, Tchia is a bit dark. It’s also a bit junky in that indie way. But overall, a very good game! A sort of Breath of the Wild and The Wind Waker hybrid. Plenty to do, collect, discover and customise.

Girl with short red hair, wearing a white jacket, dark pants and boots, glides on a zip line towards a concrete tower. Below her is a sandy desert, to her right is a large concrete building, and to her left are some white tube-shaped missile debris. On the horizon is an ominous red storm with white clouds swirling around it.
[Caravan SandWitch]

A significant element of both Caravan SandWitch and Mika and the Witch’s Mountain stories is how capitalism is ruining it for all of us. In both games you traverse a decently sized open world. You help the community, collect things and find secrets. There are non-humanoid people around, and they both have witches. The same game?

I’m kidding, but there are surprisingly many similarities, apart from the obvious: in Caravan you drive a van, but in Mika you fly on a broom. By the way, this is more platforming with gliding, less actual flying. I know, I was worried too: the ghost of Superman 64 is always looming.

They did it. They did it again. The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom is fantastic!

Princess Zelda, a blonde lady with pointed ears, wearing a white dress with blue trim, stands on the edge of a sunlit world. There are mountains in the distance. In front of her is a river with clear water, then a forest with some roads in it. In the middle of it all is a town, surrounded by a moat, with a castle in it. Everything is somewhat blocky and cartoony.
[The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom]

OK, the elephant in the room: developers, and Nintendo is no exception, have a tendency to say shit and then either the game doesn’t even have that as a problem, or it goes beyond that and is actually good, progressive, if you like. This is more or less the case here. Well, I wouldn’t call Echoes of Wisdom woke or anything, but as far as I can tell, it never makes a misstep and delivers a complete The Legend of Zelda game with Zelda as the protagonist.

And it is complete, to the point where I can’t even think of what was in BotW/TotK that isn’t here. From dungeons to shrines, from quests to secrets, from horse riding to imaginative and fun world manipulation (“hey, can I do that?… oh wow, I totally can!”).

Obviously, it has its own thing going on with the echoes mechanic, and there’s been some tweaking to make it work in flat-ish style of the Link’s Awakening remake, but it’s all there! And the game is long, too. There are also a few firsts that I won’t spoil. And cats. So many cats!

I think I mentioned somewhere that the Zelda games from Nintendo are my “problematic faves”, and I stand by that: problems ranging from questionable game elements to the firing of a harassed employee. But I think if they keep going in this direction with games (even with ridiculous claims that there needs to be a justification for these changes) and fix other shit, I won’t have to say it so often.

Summary for August 2024

Silent country

The look of the game is very pixelated and grainy. Dark-haired woman in a white short dress, black shorts and red gloves is standing in a medieval looking dungeon. There are cages, chains on the walls and bones on the floor. She stands in front of a 90’s looking computer on an office desk and says “I’m not good at computers”. There are two button prompts for the player: “(B) Leave it” and “(A) Try anyway”.
[Crow Country]

Crow Country is a good modern take on survival horror. It goes for the things that inspire it, but doesn’t forget to put its own spin on it, from aesthetics (kind of PS1 with a dash of Ečstatica) to puzzles (a pinch of Metroidvania thrown in).

Paratopic and The Sirena Expedition are nice, short, PlayStation One-looking, slightly creepy games.

Heather, a young woman with short blond hair, wearing a puffy vest and a denim skirt, stands in a dirty gray elevator. The shot is from the top back of the elevator and is very geometric.
[Silent Hill 3]

Speaking of survival horrors, I finally finished Silent Hill 3. Obligatory: fuck Konami. Has it aged? Sure, but it still holds up pretty well. To be clear, I think the graphics still look amazing. But the animation, the camera, the acting, things like that, they don’t let you forget that you’re playing a PlayStation 2 game. But at this point, it’s all part of the charm, more than anything. It’s also a sequel to the first Silent Hill, which is the only other one I’ve ever played, and that’s probably going to remain the case with this important but problematic series.

Dot’s Home is a good story about a black family, community and gentrification. It’s point-and-click only in presentation, no puzzles to speak of, almost a walking simulator, really. And it’s free!

Two girls, a brunette in jeans and a blonde in a skirt, stand in a school courtyard at night with flashlights attached to handguns. The shot is from a dirty window on the second floor of a school building and makes it look like we are spying on them.
[ObsCure]

I was also pleasantly surprised by ObsCure. Don’t get me wrong, it’s not flawless (there are at least a couple of instances of sexist stuff that come to mind, for example), but overall it wasn’t as bad as I feared. It also goes for a very specific thing, a subgenre of horror that was popular at the time (The Faculty, anyone?), to the point that, and maybe I’m reading too much into this, but the characters look like 30 years old actors playing high school kids, which is brilliant! And even with the gameplay, it does some interesting things, from the light mechanic to the ability to just break glass doors.

I also tried the sequel, and that didn’t go so well. From awkward free camera to immediate sleaze through the roof, I decided not to finish it.

In the foreground are two girls sitting on the root of a tree near the edge of a forest. The girl on the right is basically a pile of red hair with leaves stuck in it. The girl on the left is blonde, wearing slightly dirty clothes, boots, and a cloak. She has a pet falcon at her side. Everything in the foreground is warm, soft, and squiggly. They are looking at a city in the background. It is behind a wall and very square. In the background everything is cold and geometric.
[Wolfwalkers]

While Nimona is great, Wolfwalkers also has a few tricks up its sleeve. For example, the way it uses the art style to tell the story. It divides the world into a square, orderly human part and a squiggly, wild forest part. It also draws some things in that tapestry kind of way, where everything is seen from a birth-eye view, but facing the viewer. Not a bad story, nice characters, all in all a good movie.